Project#1 Health Tech Impact: An Analysis of Technological Advancements on Readmission and Mortality Rates and Data Breach Trends in Healthcare

DATA SET SOURCES: Kaggle, Datamed.gov, data.gov, statistica, Scopus ..etc

Data Sets:
Archived Supplemental Data Files | CMS. (n.d.). https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Medicare-Fee-for-Service-Payment/AcuteInpatientPPS/Archived-Supplemental-Data-Files | (Medicine et al., 2017)
Xu, H., Granger, B. B., Drake, C., Peterson, E. D., & Dupre, M. E. (2022). Effectiveness of Telemedicine Visits in Reducing 30‐Day Readmissions Among Patients With Heart Failure During the COVID‐19 Pandemic.
Journal of the American Heart Association, 11(7). https://doi.org/10.1161/jaha.121.023935
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) | CMS. (n.d.). https://www.cms.gov/medicare/medicare-fee-for-service-payment/acuteinpatientpps/readmissions-reduction-program
James JT. A new, evidence-based estimate of patient harms associated with hospital care. Journal of patient safety. 2013;9(3):122-8. 2. Suter LG, Li SX, Grady JN, Lin Z, Wang Y, Bhat KR, et al. National patterns of risk-
standardized mortality and readmission after hospitalization for acute myocardial infarction, heart failure, and pneumonia: update on publicly reported outcomes measures based on the 2013 release. Journal of general
internal medicine. 2014 Oct;29(10):1333-40. PubMed PMID: 24825244. PMCID: Pmc4175654. Epub 2014/05/16. Eng

**Step#1: Exploratory Data Analysis**

Conducted exploratory data analysis to unveil trends and patterns related to the impact of technology on healthcare outcomes and data breaches.

 

**Step#2: Literature Review and Dataset Compilation**

Carried out a thorough literature review on relevant topics and compiled and cleaned the necessary datasets for analysis. 

**Data Visualization **
- Visualized state-wise Telehealth hospital distribution using Plotly Express and Squarify.
- Analyzed the impact of telemedicine and virtual visits on patient outcomes, including readmission and mortality rates, through a stacked bar chart highlighting obstacles.
- Created a State-wise heat-map depicting the percentage of readmissions in each state.

**Step#3: Demographic Analysis**

Investigated readmission and mortality rates based on patient demographics, including age, gender, race, and socioeconomic status, utilizing pivot tables.

**Step#4: Time Series Analysis of Data Breaches**

Examined trends in healthcare industry data breaches over the past few years using time series analysis.

**Cybersecurity Strategies **
Investigated data breach trends for all states to develop effective strategies for preventing and responding to such incidents. The analysis led to the creation of a predictive model for cybersecurity priorities based on historical patterns and feedback.

This project provides a holistic view of the impact of technology on healthcare outcomes, identifies challenges in telehealth adoption, and offers insights into developing robust cybersecurity strategies for the healthcare industry.

In this comprehensive data analysis research project, I delved into various healthcare-related datasets, covering Telehealth, readmission and mortality rates, major health data breaches, telehealth scams, and Medicare 30-day re-admission penalties. The process involved multiple steps:

Research Problem Statement

The impact of health technology improvements on readmission rates, death rates, and data privacy trends in the healthcare business.

The research specifically attempts to investigate he efficacy of various technologies in enhancing patient outcomes while lowering healthcare expenses and the rates of readmissions and mortality in hospitals based on their geographical location.

The paper will also examine data privacy trends and regulations in the healthcare sector and offer viable solutions to these problems.

In order to help healthcare practitioners, policymakers, and other stakeholders make well-informed decisions about the use of technology in healthcare, the paper will address the research issues listed below.

Background

The United States Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) started the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) in 2010 as a component of the Affordable Care Act (ACA).

By penalizing hospitals with higher- than-expected readmission rates for specific diseases, the program seeks to minimize avoidable hospital readmissions.

Objective of the program

The objective of the program is to encourage hospitals to improve the standard of patient care to decrease readmissions and enhance patient outcomes.
•  The SNF VBP Program was established by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to incentivize skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) to improve the quality of care they provide to Medicare beneficiaries.
• The program evaluates SNFs based on their performance on a hospital readmission measure and scores them on both improvement and achievement, with the higher of the two scores being used.
• SNFs receive quarterly confidential feedback reports on their performance and can earn incentive payments based on their performance.
• Hospitals with higher-than-expected readmission rates are susceptible to fines under the HRRP from CMS, which are taken into consideration for both the HRRP and SNF Value-based programs.
• Heart failure (HF), pneumonia (PN), 

• Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD),
• Coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG), elective total hip arthroplasty, and/or total knee arthroplasty
(THA/TKA).

Foundation of the project

Our project is focused on analyzing two programs implemented by CMS aimed at reducing hospital readmission's.
We compared statistics from two different datasets sourced from the CMS website and incorporated physician feedback to determine penalty rates for certain health conditions.

Our aim is to provide insights and recommendations to healthcare providers and policymakers for 
patient outcomes and reducing readmission rates.

Analysis of Geographical Patterns

After Geographic pattern analysis, we considered 5 states, and they are California, Massachusetts, New York, Texas, and Florida as usage of telemedicine and other technologies is prevalent in these states and has the highest readmission penalties.

 

This section provides a thorough examination of the regional trend comparison for readmission and death rates from the perspective of an ACO. (Admission quantity, mortality rates as observed, and risk-adjustment variables) were used to visualize n tableau.

State-wise number of readmission's hospitals per state using HRRP. States like Tx, and Ca have the highest readmission %, so we took the top 5 states as KPI for further research on penalties, along with physicians’ feedback.

 Geographic Pattern Analysis

Findings& Recommendations after Heat Map 

Our Analysis, Methods and outputs

Findings

After Geographic pattern analysis, we considered 5 states, and they are California, Massachusetts, New York, Texas, and
Florida as usage of telemedicine and other technologies is prevalent in these states and has the highest readmission penalties.


We were able to uncover the numerous issues ACOs with high readmission rates encountered as well as the adverse remarks they made about telehealth thanks to our investigation. With this knowledge, we want to address the need for alternative technical advancements that can provide better remote or virtual therapy for ACOs that have been penalized for having a large number of readmissions.

Recommendation

We spoke about a few digital tools and technology that could lower fines and raise the standard of
healthcare.
1. Wearable Devices (Watches, Skin patches), Senor devices (IR Vein Scanner), EKO (ECG+ Stethoscope) which will create Synthetic data instead of PHI.
2. Asynchronous telehealth: It allows doctors to consult with patients and keep an eye on them away from their regular
offices. There could be less of a need for in-person interactions, and there might be less patient data sent via unsafe networks because it works with synthetic data produced by digital health care products.

Measure for Penalties

The penalties have been calculated using a formula that considers both the anticipated and actual readmission rates for each condition. Up to 3% of the hospital's overall Medicare payments may be deducted as penalties that are applied as a reduction in the hospital's Medicare payments.
“Depending on the hospital's rate of readmission in comparison to the national average for that condition, the fine's exact value is determined”.

EXPLORATORY DATA ANALYSIS OUTCOMES

• Count of Physicians part of the survey conducted by CMS: 500+
• Types of Datasets: Claims data (5 Health conditions) for HRRP, SNFVBP, Physicians’ feedback on
Telehealth survey, 2023 CMS facts from 2013-2023.
• Patient feedback on Usage of telehealth for the years 2015-2020.

Physician Centric Stats

Usage of telehealth rating by physicians

SSP Fast Facts Performance Year ACOs from 2012–2013 to 2023 is shown in the graph.

Over the past ten years, the Shared Savings Program (SSP) Fast Facts Performance Year ACOs have generally increased.

The number of ACOs has expanded from 220 to 456 between 2012/2013 and 2023, showing a sustained development in program participation.

The number of ACOs has, however, varied a little bit from year to year.

While there were only 404 ACOs in 2015, there was noticeable increase in ACOs in 2018 with a total of 561.

the total number of ACOs Between 2014 and 2023

Between 2014 and 2023, the total number of ACOs increased by 34%. The trend in the quantity of SSP Fast Facts Performance Year ACOs from 2012–2013 to 2023 is shown in the graph.

Findings

We were able to uncover the numerous issues ACOs with high readmission rates encountered as well as the adverse remarks they made about telehealth thanks to our investigation.

With this knowledge, we want to address the need for alternative technical advancements that can provide better remote or virtual therapy for ACOs that have been penalized for having a large number of readmissions.

Recommendation

We spoke about a few digital tools and technology that could lower fines and raise the standard of 
healthcare.
1. Wearable Devices (Watches, Skin patches), Senor devices (IR Vein Scanner), EKO (ECG+ Stethoscope) which will create Synthetic data instead of PHI.
2. Asynchronous telehealth: It allows doctors to consult with patients and keep an eye on them away from their regular
offices. There could be less of a need for in-person interactions, and there might be fewer patient data sent via unsafe networks because it works with synthetic data produced by digital health care products.

Findings& Recommendations

Mortality Rates

 The patient data volume is divided into five categories: "1384 patients".

The divisions are grouped into three categories: "1-5 divisions", "6-10 divisions", and "11-15 divisions". The heat map shows that the majority of patients are in hospitals with a volume of 25-1384 patients and are treated in 11-15 divisions. The fewest patients are treated in hospitals with a volume of >1384 patients and greater than 6 divisions.

Readmission Rates

The division with the highest density is 11-15, whereas hospitals with 456-1384 patients have the highest number of readmission patients.

The second-highest density is observed in the division of 6-10, where hospitals with 25-144 patients have the highest number of readmissions. The division of 1-5 also shows a moderate density of readmission patients, particularly in hospitals with 144- 456 patients.

Recommendations

Electronic health records (EHRs): Deploying specialty EHR applications at the network layer allows
hospitals to keep track of patient’s medical histories, prescriptions, and treatment regimens. The incidence of readmissions can be decreased by hospitals using EHRs to make sure patients receive the proper care and follow-up following discharge.
Quality of Service (QoS) applications to prioritize critical healthcare traffic, such as telemedicine consultations and real-time patient monitoring.

Geographical Data Breach Analysis

Geographical Finding& Recommendation

As a whole, under state and federal law, hospitals and other healthcare organizations in the US should expect to pay a price for data breaches involving PHI. Thus, these organizations must take the necessary actions to protect PHI and adhere to all applicable privacy and security regulations.

Our recommendations for Reducing Readmissions, also contradict data privacy, The possibility of data leaks is among the main issues surrounding wearable technology.

Wearable technology gathers private health information, including heart rate, blood pressure, and sleep habits.

It is possible to utilize this information to identify specific people and to use it maliciously.

Massachusetts

 In the event of a data breach, hospitals must notify the impacted people, the attorney general, and other governmental entities, according to the Massachusetts Data Breach Notification Law. A civil fine of up to $5,000 may be imposed for each infraction of the statute. New York: For violations of PHI, the New York State Department of Health can impose civil fines of up to $15,000. Further, hospitals must notify impacted persons, the state attorney general, and other governmental entities in the case of a data breach under the New York State Information Security Breach and Notification Act.

Florida

Healthcare organizations that neglect to protect patient data may be subject to financial penalties of up to $500,000per breach under the Florida Information Protection Act. In the event of a data breach, hospitals must also notify impacted people, the Florida Department of Legal Affairs, and other governmental organizations, according to the legislation.

Texas

Health and Safety Code of Texas, Chapter 181, mandates the implementation of adequate procedures to ensure PHI confidentially by healthcare organizations, including hospitals, as well as the notification of impacted persons and the Texas Attorney General's office in the event of a breach of unsecured PHI. A violation of the statute can result in civil fines of up to $1.5 million.


Hospitals are required by Texas Business and Commerce Code, Chapter 521, to put appropriate safeguards in place to ensure the security and privacy of sensitive personal data, including PHI.


• In the event of a breach of sensitive personal information, the legislation mandates that enterprises notify those impacted.
• It also imposes civil penalties of up to $100 for each person affected by the breach, with a maximum penalty of $50,000 per breach.

California

Infractions of the California Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) are punishable by civil fines of
up to $25,000 per patient. The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) also allows for statutory damages of up to $750 per consumer per incident, or actual losses, whichever is higher.

Key Findings to be Cost Effective

How to reduce or avoid HRRP Penalties

The CMS penalties for excessive readmission are significant, but digital technologies have the potential to help reduce violations and improve the quality of healthcare.
• By implementing digital tools correctly, healthcare providers can track and analyze patient data more effectively, identify potential issues before they escalate, and provide better care to patients.
• Digital health technologies such as electronic health records, telemedicine, and patient monitoring systems can also improve communication between healthcare providers and patients, leading to better health outcomes.

Use of telemedicine

The use of telemedicine can lower hospital readmissions and increase patient satisfaction, according to 2019 research by Chen et al. Additionally, the Skilled Nursing Facility (SNF) Penalty Program and the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) both aim to lower excessive readmissions and enhance patient outcomes.
Hospitals and skilled care homes have been subject to severe penalties under these schemes, which might have a negative financial impact on these organizations.

Adoption of digital technology

The adoption of digital technology in healthcare may enhance patient outcomes while lowering expenses, according to earlier studies.

Digital technologies, for instance, can assist patients in managing their chronic diseases and result in better health outcomes, according to research by Kujala et al. (2020).

 

Finding: As patient data is shared between various healthcare providers and technological platforms, there is a risk of data breaches or unauthorized access. As a result, interoperability and data sharing are also security concerns in digital health. Healthcare providers must
ensure that patient data is only disclosed to parties that have been given permission to do so and that data is transmitted securely using industry-standard encryption technologies.

Security Concerns:
• Data privacy
• Data Integrity
• Cyber security risk

Therefore, wearable device manufacturers must put in place the necessary security precautions to safeguard patient data. This involves putting stringent access controls in place and encrypting data while it's in transit and at rest.

Security Recommendations

Top 10 most commonly used service areas in Massachusetts FY 2022- 23 Among health providers networks,  

Top 10 most commonly used service areas in FY 2022- 23 Among health providers’ networks, As per data Ancillary division has the Highest cell count among 14 Distinct service divisions.

We have a DISTINCT COUNT OF DEPARTMENT – 43 and each department have individual divisions, and we want to propose a Network layer design to implement a Health care IT.


Strategy for EHR we recommend – Specialty-Specific EHR(Cloud applications): We propose the implementation of specialty-specific EHRs for different clinics within the network.

Network Layer

This layer manages the logical addressing and routing of data packets between different networks. Applications deployed at this layer include:
- Virtual Private Network (VPN) technology to securely connect remote clinics and providers to the main network.
- Quality of Service (QoS) applications to prioritize critical healthcare traffic, such as telemedicine consultations and real-time patient monitoring.

Data Link Layer

This layer is responsible for data transmission and error detection, providing reliable data transfer between nodes.

Applications deployed at this layer include:- Virtual Local Area Network (VLAN) segmentation to separate traffic between different departments, such as finance and patient care.
- Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) to prevent loops and improve network redundancy.

Session Layer

This layer establishes and manages communication sessions between different applications, providing mechanisms for session setup, maintenance, and teardown.

Applications deployed at this layer include:
Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) and Transport Layer Security (TLS) to secure communication channels and protect sensitive patient data.

Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP) and virtualization technologies to enable remote access to clinical applications and patient data.

Transport Layer

This layer is responsible for end-to-end data delivery, ensuring that packets are delivered reliably and in the correct order. Applications deployed at this layer include:
• Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) to provide reliable and ordered delivery of data packets.
• User Datagram Protocol (UDP) for real-time applications that require low latency, such as video conferencing and remote consultations.


Create Your Own Website With Webador